Distorting the Truth About Crime and Race Free Essay Example, 1750 words

According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that Mac Donald refutes the article of NY times by stating that they have only involved the crime rates only in their `defense`, to support their argument, rather than providing information to their readers. The Times article includes different breakdowns of the population breakdowns and racial crime rates. The author believes that the times` portrays the facts and stories in such a way to be against the police departments especially the NYPD. It is evidently clear from the discussion that they keep generalizing the facts rather than telling the true story. The times only gave the actual crime rates in 2007 but that too portrayed as the `opinion` of the police rather than real facts. They always leave the crime-related real numbers in order to support their argument. The author states that blacks are actually `under-stopped` as compared to their proportion of crimes. All the other groups are over-stepped as their stop ra tes are greater than the crimes they commit but not the blacks. She totally contradicts the times` story that the blacks are targeted by the NYPD by stating that the blacks are only 23% of the population but they committed `66% of all violent crimes` and were stopped only 55% times. She also disagrees with the solution given by the Times that NYPD`s stops should be consistent with the population ratios rather than the crime rates. We will write a custom essay sample on Distorting the Truth About Crime and Race or any topic specifically for you Only $17.96 $11.86/pageorder now This makes sense as the stops should be directly proportional to the crime rates as that is what their NYPD`s main task is: to lower the crime rates in their country. She gives the example of Compstat, a proactive style of policing, under which police officials were stationed at high-crime areas in order to stop the possibility of crimes being committed as much as possible. This was a highly effective solution as the crime rates actually dropped especially in the minority areas ruled by the blacks.